Main Stories

Judge Judy: A Taser, a Two-by-Four, and a 46-Inch TV

0:00/0:00

Two Disputes, One Unmistakable Voice

Judge Judy's courtroom rarely lacks friction, but this session serves up two very different confrontations. The first starts with a lane change on Clayton Road and escalates into a taser, a two-by-four, a swollen eye, and a teenager left behind. The second centers on a three-year relationship and an itemized list of electronics and bedroom furniture. In both, the judge's patience is tested less by the facts than by the choices people made when they were angry.

A Lane Change, a Horn, and a Taser

Henry Robichaud says he was driving down Clayton Road when he tried to change lanes. Another driver beeped his horn, so Robichaud got back into his lane. That should have been the end of it, but the other driver pulled up beside him, reached into his glove box, and pulled out a taser.

What gives the story its charge is what Robichaud thought he was seeing. At the time, he believed it was a gun. He slammed on his brakes and let the other driver pass. The road veered right; Robichaud veered with it while the other car went straight. He then continued to his son's school.

The Two-by-Four and the Teenager

The encounter did not end there. Robichaud says he got out with a two-by-four and told the other man to put the taser away. He insists he was not “jumping around out there” and that he acted partly to protect the teenager with him. Then he got back into his truck.

Judge Judy seizes on what happened next. You left him there with the guy? she asks. Robichaud acknowledges that he did, while maintaining that he made sure the taser was put away. When she asks where the weapon went, he says he does not know; he thinks the man put it in his pocket.

You left him there with the guy?

The exchange exposes the gap between Robichaud's stated concern and his behavior. He says he did not want the teenager to get tased, yet he admits leaving the teenager behind with the man he says was holding the taser.

A Punch, a Truck, and a Question of Age

Josh gives his own account of the argument. He says he walked out of Robichaud's front door, and Robichaud came outside screaming about the door being slammed. Josh tried to get away, but then walked back toward the porch to ask for money he was owed and a dirt bike he says was promised for work he had done. Robichaud said no, according to Josh, and punched him.

Josh says he yelled for his father and mother to come down. As Robichaud walked toward him, Josh hit his truck.

Robichaud's version is different in the details and nearly identical in its lack of introspection. He says Josh slammed the door, so he followed him outside. When Judge Judy asks how Josh's eye became swollen and bleeding, Robichaud says Josh swung at him, he blocked the punch, and Josh hit himself in the face. He adds that Josh's hand bounced off his hand.

The explanation does not appear to impress the judge. She tells Robichaud to take his hands out of his pockets and uncross his hands, then establishes the contrast at the center of the case: Robichaud is 41. Josh is 17.

The Cell Phone Test

Judge Judy then asks whether Robichaud has a cell phone. He says he does but did not have it with him. She wants a yes or a no. She tells him she does not believe that he left without it.

Her reasoning is practical. If he truly had no phone, he did not need to run out with a two-by-four. He could have gone to another car and asked someone to call 911. Instead, he chose a weapon and a confrontation.

You didn't act like a responsible adult that day.

Judge Judy is not moved by his protest. I win. You lose. Robichaud's case is dismissed, and she awards $500 on the counterclaim.

A Breakup, a 46-Inch Plasma TV, and Bedroom Furniture

The second dispute shifts from road rage to domestic fallout. Twenty-year-old Jorge George Cardenas is suing Jennifer Aguilera, the 22-year-old mother of his child, for the return of his electronic equipment and bedroom furniture. According to the complaint, they were in a relationship as young teenagers, had a baby, and moved in with Aguilera's parents.

The arrangement lasted about three years, beginning in 2005. Cardenas moved out in August 2008. He says Aguilera will not return things he bought while he lived in the house. The list includes a digital camera, a video recorder, a 46-inch plasma TV, a Dell computer, and bedroom furniture.

No Courts for Playing House

Judge Judy is less interested in the inventory than in the legal reality. The couple was not married. They set up housekeeping together, and now they want a court to sort through the remains.

Two people decide to play house. We don't have courts for people playing house.

She says she will not go through the bank account to determine who put in what. As far as she is concerned, there are no rules for people who are not married. They should have worried about the consequences afterward, not asked the court to reconstruct a three-year relationship.

Get a Job

The furniture becomes the final flashpoint. Judge Judy asks who is paying for it. Aguilera says she is and has been for the past eight months. The judge presses, and the answer does not satisfy her. She asks whether Aguilera has a job. The answer is no.

Judge Judy tells Aguilera that Cardenas is coming to get the furniture and the other items in five days. Aguilera asks the question that captures the fear beneath the dispute: So we're supposed to sleep on the floor?

I don't care. I don't care. No, get a job. You want furniture, get a job. But he's not going to pay for furniture for you. You're not his wife. The only thing he's responsible to pay for is his child.

The response is harsh but consistent with the judge's view: the court will not treat an unmarried relationship like a marriage with a built-in property settlement. Cardenas may be responsible for his child, but he is not responsible for furnishing Aguilera's home.

The Common Thread

Both hearings turn on the same demand: take responsibility for your choices. Robichaud wanted to be seen as the victim of a road-rage aggressor, but leaving a teenager behind with the man he feared undermined that story. Cardenas wanted his belongings back, but the judge focused on the absence of a marriage and the limits of what a court would untangle.

The memorable moments are the short questions that strip away the excuses: You left him there with the guy? How old are you? Do you have a job? In each case, the answer does more damage than any argument.

Source: Guria Crocheteira e Arteira on YouTube

How did this story make you feel?

😀
0
😍
0
😢
0
😡
0
👍
0
👎
0