“No. I want the hall.”
“Then we’ll trim the menu. Your wedding still happens.”
Afterward, I stared at him.
“You didn’t tell her what to choose.”
“I’ve had twelve years to hear how I sounded.”
He slid the revised food estimate toward me. He’d cut his event fee to keep the hall affordable.
“You don’t have to buy forgiveness,” I said.
“It’s Paige’s wedding. You don’t owe me anything.”
That evening, beneath the hall’s work lights, I held a ladder while he tested a loose curtain hook.
“I wasn’t asking you to stop loving me,” I said. “I was asking you to love someone with a bus to catch.”
He climbed down.
“I thought needing me meant staying.”
“I did need you.”
His hand stopped beside mine on the ladder.
“Past tense?”
I didn’t move my hand.
Then his open folder slipped off the chair.
The offer landed faceup between us.
“Cleveland?” I said. “You knew I was moving back, didn’t you?”
“Paige told me last month.”
“And you didn’t mention this?”
“I wanted dinner before we talked about it.”
“A dinner under another name. Then a job in my city.” I stepped away. “Have you arranged another life for us without asking me?”
“Erin—”
“I’ll finish the plans. Paige won’t lose her wedding. But we’re done here.”
He let me leave.
On Saturday, I arrived with the seating chart. Daniel was by the kitchen door beside Paige, who held her phone toward him.
“Tell her what you told me,” she said.
“Don’t,” I said. “Not for an audience.”
Daniel nodded and followed me into the empty entryway.
“The Cleveland offer was signed six weeks ago,” he said. “Look at the date. Before Paige told me you were moving.”
I read it twice.
“Then why hide it?”
“Because I wanted you to think we were possible before you decided it was another trap. I chose what you got to know. Again.”
His eyes shone.
“I called this morning. Asked for separate relocation housing. Lost the deposit on the bigger place I’d picked after I heard about you.”
“You assumed I’d move in?”
“I hoped. Then I started treating hope like permission.”
He held out his phone. Two separate addresses. His new apartment; the office where he’d start Monday.
“No ring beside a ticket,” he said. “Dinner after work. You choose the night. You get to say no.”
I watched his face as I took his hand.
“Thursday. And tell me things before you’re afraid I’ll leave.”
“Even those things.”
Six months later, we signed a lease together after touring four apartments and arguing honestly about all four.
“Both names?” the manager asked.
“Both,” I said.
Daniel handed me my own set of keys. At home, he waited while I opened our door.
This time, staying was my choice.
The end · Your turn
Was Erin right to give him another chance after he hid the job offer?
Tell us what you think in the comments on Facebook.


