Dynatashia Ware wants $5,000 for emotional distress over an attempted car repossession. Bernard Williams says he was there to recover the vehicle. Between those positions lies a disputed encounter in a pizza restaurant parking lot, an argument about who said what, and one fact Judge Judy repeatedly brings back into focus: Ware still has the car and acknowledges missing payments.
The strongest exchanges come as Judy separates the competing accounts into specific questions. Did Williams identify himself? Did he enter the back seat? Had Ware already received calls about repossession? Each answer changes the emphasis of a hearing that ends with dismissal of Ware’s claim and an order to return the vehicle immediately.
A Parking Lot Encounter Meets Immediate Skepticism
Ware places the incident on April 17, 2009, outside a Little Caesar Pizza near her home. Her husband had gone inside, she says, when Williams entered her car while she was sitting in it. According to Ware, he did not identify himself or explain his purpose.
Judy accepts one part of that account while challenging another. She believes Williams entered the car, but doubts that he failed to say he was repossessing it. Her response is direct:
That doesn’t make sense to me.
Ware maintains that he did not say who he was. She explains that the tow truck and Williams’s wife recording the encounter were what revealed the attempted repossession. That distinction establishes the first major dispute: the entry itself is one question; the explanation accompanying it is another.
The $5,000 Request Comes Into Focus
The questioning becomes particularly pointed when Judy asks whether Ware still has the car. Ware initially responds that the police gave it back to her. Judy repeats the question and turns to the payment history.
Ware confirms that she made no payment in April and none in May. Judy then puts the circumstances alongside the requested compensation: Ware remains in possession of a vehicle she has not paid for and wants $5,000 from the people who tried to repossess it.
Ware says yes. The exchange is compelling because Judy reduces a sprawling disagreement to a clearly stated claim. Whatever happened during the attempted repossession, the continued possession and missed payments are central to how she views Ware’s position.
“I Have Zero Sympathy”
Judy’s sharpest criticism concerns what happened after the encounter. She argues that once Ware knew the vehicle was being sought, she should have returned it if she could not afford it.
So I have zero sympathy for that position.
Ware responds that there is a way to handle these situations and says she has been trying to make arrangements with Westlake. She also asserts that Williams is no longer assigned to repossess the vehicle. Judy continues to focus on the unpaid installments and Ware’s decision to keep the car.
The tension here comes from their different emphases. Ware wants the manner of the repossession addressed. Judy insists that Ware also account for her continuing possession of the vehicle.
Williams Faces a Direct Question
Williams receives his own forceful questioning. Asked whether he got into the back of the car, he first says the door was open. Judy refuses to let that detail substitute for an answer.
Let’s not play with each other.
Williams then confirms that he entered the back seat while Ware was in the driver’s seat. He says he introduced himself beforehand, identified his repossession company and explained that they were taking the car. He also says he wore credentials around his neck.
When Williams claims he was invited into the back seat, Judy identifies the entry as the alleged trespass at issue. It is an important moment: her criticism of Ware’s nonpayment does not prevent her from pressing Williams about his conduct.
The Police Account Adds Another Dispute
Judy reads from a police transcript describing a report that the repossession agent entered the back seat to prevent Ware from taking the vehicle. Ware disputes the wording. Judy answers that it is what the document says.
The account also describes a drive home and allegations that Williams was punched and held against his will. Williams says Ware wanted to go home to unload belongings and pizza for her children. The reported allegations bring another layer to the hearing, but they remain allegations within the exchange.
Williams explains that he did not press charges because his aim was recovering the vehicle: “It’s nothing personal.”
Earlier Phone Calls Become Crucial
One of the most consequential moments begins with information Ware volunteers. She says she knew who Williams was because he had been calling her phone.
Asked when those calls began, Ware says approximately a week before the incident. Judy connects that answer to prior notice that the financial institution wanted the car back. Ware disputes the framing of the earlier questioning, and the exchange grows more heated.
For Judy, the calls become a significant part of the explanation for her eventual decision. They bear directly on whether the attempted repossession came without warning.
A Dismissal and an Immediate Return Order
Judy dismisses Ware’s claim in its entirety, states that she believes Williams and finds that Ware had notice of the attempted repossession. Her clearest statement of the reasoning is also one of the hearing’s most memorable lines:
You don’t get a windfall because you don’t like the way they were trying to get their property back.
She separately addresses Williams’s assault counterclaim, encouraging him to pursue the matter criminally. The supplied exchange establishes no later criminal outcome.
The final directive is concrete: Judy issues an order requiring Ware to return the car immediately, with assistance from a marshal available to Williams. After repeated disputes over identification, entry and notice, the hearing closes on the issue Judy has consistently emphasized—Ware cannot continue keeping the vehicle without paying for it.
Source: Jiayan Foodie on YouTube


